[Citizen Journalism] Perspective of a 17 year old Muslim girl towards Amos Yee Saga

“.. one change I want to see is that.. Youths be more.. actually the whole country as large to be more open in that sense to criticism.”

* DISCLAIMER:

1) The articles of any online sites using quotes from our interviews are not representative of Offbeat Perspectives vision, mission, and aims, nor are we affiliated to any website. We are independently run as simply, Offbeat Perspectives.

2) We respect the opinions expressed by our interviewees, but it should not be interpreted as that of Offbeat Perspectives. Our role is to act as a platform to share the diverse views of people.

20150705_180614

Ranette Age: 17 Gender: Female Race: Chinese – Malay (* Mum has Australian blood) Religious Belief: Muslim

  • Student

“ I think there are different responses from the public e.g. the many negative comments, but there are also people who support him. And I think it should just be a Youtube Video with people commenting on it and sharing their opinions. I don’t think that it should get so much involved with the government over this issue.

222

Do you feel he should have said out the same ideas, but just changed the way he say it, like in a more responsible or respectful manner?

Ya. That is my personal opinion. I understand his points about the government, income equality in Singapore and how he says that LKY is a dictator. I don’t necessarily think he’s a dictator but he has some traits of a dictator. Overall, I think the way he says it, if you want people to listen to him(you), he should not have been so.., in a way offensive. If he put his points across in a more logical, less offensive manner, then people would listen to his points more instead of getting very emotionally affected about what his said – like all the vulgarities and all that.

So you felt his points were not that logical even though he showed facts?

No, I find all his points logical. The only problem is the way he put his videos and the vulgarities that he said and some of the images but at the same time, that may be his purpose. He put a very loud video so that more people will hear him. But he should not get arrested for that.

222

Everyone that I interviewed kind of focuses on the LKY comment but everyone seemed to forget about the racial aspects and religious aspects. Is this because you all feel that the sentence was politically motivated? * (she misinterpreted “sentence” (punishment) as “sentence” (a set of words with a full stop.)

I think that his sentence was politically motivated. In my opinion, Amos Yee is an attention seeker. Even though he has political motives, he uses very personal issues like Christianity to make his videos more attention-seeking. Because he wants more people to see the videos and hear his political motives.

I would say people don’t focus on the Christianity part because of how much is focused at the political part of Singapore, that’s why they put that part aside. The people you interview here are more talk about political than religious (would prefer to converse more on political than religious aspects of an issue.

222

If he expressed the same ideas but this time towards Islam, would you feel offended as well?

Of course as a Muslim, if all of these like that e.g. ISIS and all there, of course you would feel affected. I mean as a person, but I do not go out and make police reports about this kind of thing. People have their own opinions.

If Amos Yee videos called upon all Singaporeans, all non-Christians to rally up against and protest against Christianity, I think that is something I would disagree but, he is just stating what he thinks about Christianity. So if he says the same thing about Islam which is a religion, I would be affected but I wouldn’t do anything about it.

For religious groups with more conservative mindsets, do you feel that they should be more opened, and not feel offended by his actions?

Ya, I don’t think that anybody should feel offe.. ok you can feel offended but you do not need to make a police report and then arrest him for all that and what he said. 3333 But then if it continues to become a normal trend and everyone starts to talk bad about different races and religion, how do you think the government should deal with the whole situation?

I think the government should deal with the situation by simply e.g. stop them from putting up these posts by imposing fines or creating laws. Charge them for posting all these things but not to the extent of arresting them and such. Maybe Singapore (can have) these kinds of censorship where they don’t allow certain content, but not to the extent of arresting him. Again in the video, he never ask for anybody to do anything against Christianity. So it’s not something that the government can say “ Oh you know, you caused people to like.. social unrest and all that”.  

As the younger generation, what is one change you would like to see in Singapore?

I think there is a lot of freedom of speech in the social media. Everybody can say whatever they want to say but one change I want to see is that.. Youths be more.. actually the whole country as large to be more open in that sense to criticism. I think if the country is strong enough and stable enough, no matter how many criticisms are thrown at us, we would not be affected by it.

Of course we would take it, but if it’s not true, we should just ignore it. If it’s true, just to try and improve on it, and not get so emotionally affected. What I hope to see is for people to be more opened and not be easily affected by all these comments if they do not think it is true.” 22222 Is there a way you would suggest to make people more open-minded?

I think a good start would be like television, all those talks shows that I actually watch on Channel 5 e.g. Talking Point, they talk about all these political issues and they do not just have government figures. When they are talking about transportation, they have like, bus driver, taxi driver and even a student talking about transportation issues.

These are good initiatives in which all the perspectives can be explored.  I wouldn’t say these are propaganda because it not just a government figure talking about how good everything is. So that is a start, so more of these kind of forums and talk shows can start people realizing they don’t have to agree with everything but they don’t have to act out so much either when they don’t agree with it.”

20150705_165729

“ I think if the country is strong enough and stable enough, no matter how many criticisms are thrown at us, we would not be affected by it.”

Stay tune to… A teacher’s perspective on the Amos Yee Saga in the days ahead.

Food For Thought:

What’s your opinion towards Ranette saying that:

1. The government should/need not have gotten so involved so much Amos Yee video?

2. Lee Kuan Yew having some traits of a dictator?

3. Amos Yee words were logical?

4. Amos Yee should not have gotten arrested for his video?

5. People should not feel offended by what Amos Yee said in his video?

6. What Amos Yee did would most likely not cause social unrest?

7. Singaporeans as a whole should be more open to criticism?Written by: Cass

[Offbeat Perspective’s Interviews]

Category: “Film”

11165280_659103497551639_7032000631426860885_n   Director Tzang (Faeryville)

maxresdefault  Farid Assalam (actor from Faeryville)

images  Lyon Sim actor from (Faeryville)

Category: “Unique Passions”

1

Unique Passions: Budding Street photographer Paris Chia Part I (An eye for photography with a human touch)

1

Unique Passions: Budding Street photographer Paris Chia Part II (Indie Boy vs Mainstream Ideals)

20150920_130739

Unique Passions: The sentiments of a born-and-bred construction worker in Singapore

Category: “Unheard Voices”

20150901_092122

Unheard Voices: Once a bullied victim, now a youth protector

17905880795_e0481ef465_o-2

Unheard Voices: The memoir of a Singaporean Transgender Sex Worker

Category: “Public Interviews”

20150817_191908

Golden Years Edition Part I: Interviewing the elderly on their views towards the government

Golden Years Edition Part II: Interviewing the elderly on their views towards the government 

Category: “Amos Yee Saga – Citizen Journalism”

1

Voices of Hong Lim Park Part I

Voices of Hong Lim Park Part II

Perspective of a 17 year old Muslim girl in Singapore towards Amos Yee Saga

A Singaporean teacher’s perspective towards Amos Yee Saga

PAP has lost my vote. Permanently forever.

To check out more of our posts on the Amos Yee Saga, click HERE

1

Click  HERE if you want to check out our Facebook page for new updates 🙂

 

Advertisements

16 thoughts on “[Citizen Journalism] Perspective of a 17 year old Muslim girl towards Amos Yee Saga

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s